Turkish dictator Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is a bully, like most right-wing dictators he is a nationalist and does not like criticism of the ”almighty” Turkish Republic. Turkish nationalism is a huge problem as it has undermined the freedom of all Turkish workers. For the first time, the U.S funded Freedom House has declared Turkey to be a not-free state. This makes the kingdom of Recep Tayyip Erdoğan the only actual dictatorship that is part of NATO. Ankara is famous for bullying countries who show any solidarity with the oppressed Kurdish people. Recently the Norwegians were attacked by Ankara for showing a wall painting of Kurdish women. The Turkish state was offended and the cultural centre that showed the painting received threats and insults from Turkish nationalists. Since the Turkish far-right is in league with the conservatives of Erdoğan, it is no surprise that Turkey is now officially no longer called a free nation by Freedom House.
”NATO promotes democratic values and enables members to consult and cooperate on defence and security-related issues to solve problems, build trust and, in the long run, prevent conflict’
This is the first propaganda line of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation on their website. Turkey is a member of this military alliance since 1952. NATO was not formed as a democratic bastion, it was created to protect western capitalism from a potential Soviet attack. The western alliance used democracy as a façade just as the Warsaw Pact used socialism. In all of Turkish history, the nation was never a genuine democracy or a full free nation. Turkish nationalism is the main reason for this fact. When the republic was founded in 1923, right-wing nationalism was printed in its constitution. The intolerance of the nationalists who founded the Turkish Republic, is shown in the massacre of the first Communist Party of Turkey in 1921.
Mustafa Kemal Atatürk led the first Turkish Republic from 1923 until his death in 1938. He did not tolerated opposition to his Republican People’s Party. It would not be until 1944 that the party of Atatürk introduced a multi-party system. However the Turkish state would never show any respect towards those who said NO to Atatürk legacy. In the 71 years since Turkey joined NATO, there has been two coups and many undemocratic attacks on the political rights of minorities. Kurds are the main victims of Turkish nationalism. Since the military coup of 1980, Turkey has banned over 20 political parties. Even the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) was almost banned in 2003 for violating the secular constitution.
Kurds have always been oppressed by the nationalist state. This is because Turkey does not recognise minorities. All people who live in Turkey are meant to be Turks. This means they have to speak Turkish and behave culturally Turkish. Kurds have always been regarded as a mountainous Turkish people by the state, although this is not correct. Kurds are a Iranian people, they are not ethnic Turkish. Despite this fact, the Turkish Republic of 1923 oppressed them and force the Turkish language and culture on them. This is why the Kurdish generation born in the last century, could not even speak their own native language. Fifty years of right-wing Turkish nationalism had resulted in the fact that many Kurds did not knew their history and culture.
The foundation of the Kurdistan Workers Party in 1978 was a milestone for Kurds in Turkey. Had it not been for the cruel and abusive ways of the Turkish state, the PKK might never have been so violent. PKK violence rose as a reaction to the crimes of the Turkish government, this fact is ignored by America, Europe and the Turkish Republic itself. When Abdullah Öcalan and his supporters began, few could speak Kurdish. Abdullah Öcalan himself could not speak it, because he was part of the generation who was never told to speak Kurdish at home. After brutal crackdowns of PKK activists between 1978 and 1984, the organisation decided to set up a rebel army to fight back. The People’s Liberation Army of Kurdistan was the armed wing of the Kurdistan Workers Party, it was renamed People’s Defence Forces in 2000.
NATO supplies Turkey with the weapons to oppress not only the Kurds but also anti-nationalist Turks. This makes NATO co-responsible for any victim of the AK Party and its far-right allies of the Nationalist Movement Party. (MHP). Erdogan needs the support of Turkish fascists in order to stay in power. His conservative party does not have the majority of seats in parliament. This is why they joined up with the far-right, who has no problems with a authoritarian capitalist tyrant like Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Turkish nationalism is a smoke screen used to hide the abuses carried out under the AK Party. Since Turks are raised as nationalists, they are told at schools, at work and by their political leaders not to question the nationalist nature of the state.
Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has abused this dogmatic intolerance to build up his nationalist dictatorship. Turkey under him slipped slowly from a partly free nation into a not free nation. It needed 20 years, but now there is no way to change the country by democratic means. The 2016 coup attempt by parts of the military gave the dictator more nationalist supporters. Erdogan purged over 48.000 government workers, most were not part of the coup or even supported it. They were all replaced by royal puppets, so the 2016 coup attempt gave the AK Party the final push to remove their critics inside the state apparatus. Erdogan claims that he is defending ”democracy” and ”liberty”. Reality is that he has destroyed the few democratic freedoms the Turks had.
Countries who stand up for Kurdish and other minority rights are bullied by not only the Turkish Republic but also Turkish nationalists and fascists. In countries with a large Turkish minority, Erdogan has a strong base of support. Germany has over four million people with Turkish origins. The Netherlands can count up to one to 1,5 million people with Turkish roots. Around 70% of all ethnic Turks in both Germany and the Netherlands are loyal to the Justice and Development Party (AK Party). This because they originated from rural Turkey, the base of support for the AK Party. While most working class Turks in the cities reject Erdogan, the peasants and poor in the countryside are pro-Erdogan.
These rural Turks who migrated to Europe kept a strong bond with conservative Turkey. After Recep Tayyip Erdoğan first became prime minster in 2002, they were his core supporters. It is thanks to rural Turks that Erdogan was able to win all elections since 2002. Their conservative and religious background made them perfect pawns, because the secularists of Turkey were all living in the cities. The secular constitution was their product as Mustafa Kemal Atatürk was a secular leader, who wanted religion and state separated. Rural Turks never liked this and Erdogan’s use of conservative populism mixed with Islamic values turned them towards him. Now these Turks bully and intimidate their opponents even outside Turkey.
They raise their children with dogmatism and intolerance for anybody who shows solidarity with the Kurds. The fact that the Kurdistan Workers Party has been labelled a ”terrorist” organisation works in the favour of these nationalists and fascists. Most European government labelled the PKK ”terrorist” in a attempt to get the secular Turks to join the European Union in the 1990’s. Also they claimed that the PKK was terrorist because their armed wing carried out suicide attacks. However the African National Congress led by Nelson Mandela also used terrorism against Apartheid. Mandela renounced terrorism in 1990 and the PKK no longer uses suicide bombers. PKK attacks are now mainly directed against soldiers and police.
In 2018 a Belgian court ruled that the party of Abdullah Öcalan is not terrorist, because they no longer use terrorist methods. Also they fight a legitimate struggle against a oppressive government. The Belgian state said that it would not change anything, for the Kingdom of Belgium the PKK remains ”terrorist” despite their courts telling otherwise. Any solidarity of European organisations with the PKK in Turkey or the PYD in Syria can result in Turkish nationalist protests, intimidations and death threats. Because we are talking here about far-right Turks being allowed to spread their poison and hate. They hide their racism and nationalism under a façade of promoting Turkish culture. The Dutch and German governments should not tolerant Turkish ”cultural groups” who promote nationalist singers and far-right speakers.
Let us not forget that Turkish nationalists and fascists are free to bully and intimidate, because Ankara is pushing them. Erdogan is using his supporters in Europe to do the very things he is carrying out in Turkey. He wants Turks in Europe to act intolerant so that anti-Turkish sentiments rise among Europeans. It will then allow the Turkish government to portray Europe as ”fascist”. Recep Tayyip Erdoğan wants to divide the working class of Europe, like all far-right leaders do. It is up to revolutionary socialists to unite workers from all countries and ethnicities. Turkish imperialism and nationalism must be rejected. At the same time we must point out that only class struggle can overthrow Erdogan, not guerrilla warfare by ethnic minorities and small far-left groups.